Season 7 – November 2, 2019 to April 28, 2020
- Episode 1, The Torch is Passed (November 2, 2019). The Oak Island team opened the season by observing a moment of silence for Dan Blankenship and committing to continue the search in his memory. Members reviewed seismic data indicating a roughly 200-foot-long, ship-shaped anomaly beneath the swamp, while emphasizing that its identity remained unconfirmed. Diver Tony Sampson identified a straight, flat stone feature near the anomaly that might have been a roadway or wharf; surveyor Steve Guptill mapped it, and the team decided to drill core samples for evidence of wood before considering excavation. A floating barge and sonic drill were assembled and drilling began, but no results were reported in the excerpt. Tom Nolan joined the team full-time, continuing the swamp investigation pursued by his late father, Fred Nolan. At Smith’s Cove, the team planned a permitted cofferdam expansion to expose more of the previously dated 1769 slipway and search for artifacts or additional structures; the Money Pit strategy remained under review, with further research and possible sonic drilling discussed. At nearby Isaac’s Point, Gary Drayton and colleagues recovered a silver-plated button, a likely nineteenth-century hand mirror, and an iron object initially thought to be a spike. Conservator Kelly Bourassa dated the button’s type to approximately 1726–1776, broadly consistent with the slipway’s age, although its origin and possible military use remained uncertain. Blacksmith Carmen Legge identified the iron object as a stonemason’s hand-point chisel, likely predating 1800 and potentially much older, but could not narrow its date further.
- Episode 2, Core Values (November 12, 2019). The Oak Island team used exploratory core drilling to investigate a seismic anomaly that might have been a buried ship before committing to the expense of draining and excavating the swamp. The cores revealed unusually dry clay but no ship timbers or other conclusive evidence of a structure; a hard, rock-like layer stopped drilling at one site. Wetland geoscientist Dr. Ian Spooner observed marine sediment beneath a relatively thin organic layer and preliminarily suggested that the area had once been open water and that the swamp might be younger than expected. He took samples for laboratory analysis to assess its age and possible human modification. At Smith’s Cove and the nearby cave-in pit, ground-penetrating radar identified anomalies, including signals approximately 90–100 feet deep, that the team considered worthy of further investigation for possible flood tunnels. On Lot 21, Rick Lagina, Dan Henskee and Gary Drayton found two iron objects initially thought to be quarry hammers; blacksmith Carmen Legge identified them as swages used to sharpen rock drills and estimated that they could date from the mid-1400s to approximately 1750. The team considered whether the tools indicated historical tunneling or mining on the island’s western side, although their connection to the treasure search remained unproven. Despite the inconclusive drilling results, team members noted that the dry clay might have allowed tunneling beneath the swamp. They agreed to pursue a science-based assessment of the swamp’s development and to define a potential excavation target, depth, method and permitting requirements before proceeding.
- Episode 3, Eye of the Swamp (November 19, 2019). Environmental geoscientist Dr. Ian Spooner reported that preliminary sediment analysis suggested the Oak Island swamp might be only 300–400 years old and possibly altered by humans, although its origin remained unproven. He also identified an unusual oval feature at the swamp’s northern end, where probing suggested a perimeter of rocks. Marty Lagina’s team investigated the “eye,” mapped rocks and repeated iron-detection signals, and agreed to drain the swamp for a closer examination. The team had a drainage permit but still needed an excavation permit. Contractor Sean Wilson proposed using rig mats and trench cages to isolate excavation areas and contain unstable peat; the planned targets included the eye, a possible stone roadway, and a 200-foot-long anomaly previously identified by seismic scanning. At Saint Mary’s University, researchers analyzed iron swages identified as tools for sharpening rock chisels. The absence of detectable manganese was interpreted as consistent with a pre-1840 date, though it did not establish a precise age or link the tools to treasure-related tunneling. At Smith’s Cove, the team began sonic drilling to investigate a possible connection between previously identified stone drains and the Money Pit. A core from approximately 95 feet contained disturbed material and apparent dynamite remnants, which the team associated with an 1897–1898 attempt to disable the purported flood system. They planned further drilling along the suspected route, but had not located a tunnel.
- Episode 4, The Lucky Thirteen (November 26, 2019). The Oak Island team discussed sonic drilling at Smith’s Cove, where timber fragments found approximately 51–54 feet deep, with apparently undisturbed ground above and below, suggested a possible buried structure or tunnel. The location aligned with several previously identified features and the Money Pit area, although a subsequent borehole did not find wood. Radiocarbon analysis placed the most likely date of the timber between 1735 and 1784, before the reported 1795 discovery of the Money Pit. The team agreed that the result was promising but did not establish the structure’s purpose, and decided to continue drilling to verify it and determine its direction before considering excavation. For the swamp, Rick Lagina, Craig Tester, and landowner Tom Nolan discussed removing accumulated vegetation and excavating several potential targets, subject to the necessary permits. An inflatable-dam specialist considered a temporary barrier around approximately one acre feasible, and the team planned to compare methods before choosing an approach. On Lot 21, Gary Drayton and Charles Barkhouse found a copper coin tentatively dated to the 1840s and an ornate object thought to be a brooch or similar fitting. A conservator cleaned the object and noted a rope-like design but found no maker’s mark and could not determine its age or origin; proposed historical connections remained speculative. The team decided to pursue further specialist assessment and consider nonintrusive archaeological investigation, including ground-penetrating radar, on Lot 21.
- Episode 5, Tunnel Visions (December 3, 2019). The Oak Island team investigated a possible flood tunnel between Smith’s Cove and the original Money Pit. Ground-penetrating radar had identified anomalies, and an earlier borehole recovered hand-cut timbers dated to approximately 1735–1784. A subsequent core at roughly 100 feet contained four feet of sand between consolidated soils, consistent with historical descriptions of a sand-filled tunnel; however, a second borehole five feet away did not produce comparable evidence. The team therefore decided to use seismic mapping rather than continue random drilling, commissioning Eagle Canada to survey the island’s eastern area. On the former McGinnis properties, Gary Drayton identified an iron object as a possible rock chisel, potentially associated with previously discovered drilling tools, though its age and purpose remained unconfirmed. A ground-penetrating radar survey near the McGinnis foundation also identified disturbed soil and an unidentified anomaly approximately four feet below ground; archaeologist Laird Niven planned to use the data to support a permit application for excavation. Naval historian Chip Reid proposed that the Smith’s Cove structures resembled a coastal artillery fortification and suggested a possible connection to French military activity and treasure moved from Louisbourg, while acknowledging that related historical documents required verification. Finally, following information supplied by Dan Henskee, Rick and Marty Lagina uncovered a well-preserved wooden sluiceway on the southern shore that appeared still to be carrying water. They planned to trace it toward the nineteenth-century shaft nine, whose documented position could help establish the original Money Pit’s location.
- Episode 6, Closing In (December 10, 2019). Using information from veteran treasure hunter Dan Henskee, the team traced an 1863 sluiceway toward shaft nine, a historical search shaft that could help establish the original Money Pit’s location. Surveyor Steve Guptill mapped the sluiceway, and excavation uncovered a timber structure measuring approximately six by twelve feet; its connection to the sluiceway confirmed it as shaft nine. The team planned to analyze the measurements and historical maps to identify where to search next. Eagle Canada completed an extensive seismic survey across the island’s eastern half, including Smith’s Cove, the Cave-in Pit and the Highlands, to identify possible underground structures and flood-tunnel connections. The survey used explosive charges and geophones, with results expected after several weeks of processing. Near the swamp, Gary Drayton and Peter Fornetti found two iron spikes resembling maritime and cribbing hardware. Blacksmithing expert Carmen Legge identified one as a corroded shipbuilding or decking spike that could date from the sixteenth through eighteenth centuries, though he could not assign a precise date. Journalist and author Darcy O’Connor presented his hypothesis that a Spanish galleon had been driven to Oak Island and its crew had hidden treasure protected by flood tunnels. He cited historical shipping routes and previously found artifacts as supporting context, while acknowledging that the theory remained unproven.
- Episode 7, Things That Go Bump-out (December 17, 2019). The Oak Island team expanded the Smith’s Cove cofferdam by approximately 6,000 square feet to investigate an area beyond the previously excavated slipway. After draining the extension, the team examined a previously undocumented wooden structure, along with tar paper, stacked rocks and flowing water; members considered a possible connection to the reported flood-tunnel system but agreed that further excavation was needed. At the Money Pit, the team used the recently identified shaft nine, historical measurements and a 1931 aerial photograph to estimate the location of shaft two, which historical accounts placed approximately 14 feet from the original pit. Sonic drilling encountered disturbed soil and stacked timbers consistent with a shaft wall, and Rick Lagina directed the team to continue drilling and test adjacent locations before confirming its identity. Separately, Rick and colleagues investigated a report that the missing ninety-foot stone might be buried on the grounds of the Helen Creighton Heritage Museum. They did not find it during the visit and decided to seek a government permit for an archaeological excavation. On lot six, Jack Begley and Gary Drayton recovered corroded iron pins and a large spike that Drayton believed could date to the eighteenth century; they proposed that the finds might indicate a former wharf or other substantial waterfront structure, though its age and purpose remained unconfirmed.
- Episode 8, Triptych (January 7, 2020). At Smith’s Cove, the team uncovered a previously undocumented wooden, shaft-like structure surrounded by extensive rockwork, possibly including a working platform. Members considered whether it was associated with a historical search effort or a stone box drain, but its age, purpose and relationship to the reported flooding system remained uncertain. A hand-worked iron spike resembled finds from a nearby slipway dated to approximately 1769, although it did not establish the new structure’s age. The team decided to continue excavating from north to south rather than immediately expose the entire shaft, preserving site access and allowing for archaeological precision and safety. Researcher Corian Mall presented a theory that clues in Nicolas Poussin’s paintings pointed to treasure, potentially including the Ark of the Covenant, in the Oak Island swamp; the team treated the proposed connections as leads for investigation. Ground-penetrating radar subsequently detected an anomaly approximately three meters deep and six meters wide near one of Mall’s proposed locations, prompting plans for further scanning and possible excavation. In the Money Pit area, exploratory boreholes recovered worked wood that appeared to define two walls of a shaft. Dendrochronology returned a date of 1796, consistent with construction of Shaft Two in 1805, and the team concluded that the structure was likely Shaft Two. Because historical accounts placed that shaft approximately 14 feet from the original Money Pit, the team planned further drilling and modeling to establish its orientation and narrow the pit’s location; the precise location remained unconfirmed.
- Episode 9, An Eye for an Eye (January 14, 2020). The Oak Island team discussed using the believed location of Shaft 2 as a reference point to locate its historical tunnel and narrow the search for the original Money Pit. Drilling at borehole F-14 recovered material that the team interpreted as part of a tunnel at approximately 100 feet; they proposed drilling F-15 to determine its direction. At Smith’s Cove, the team postponed further excavation of a previously discovered log shaft to preserve access to the wider site and instead investigated an extensive structure of large timbers, wooden pegs and boulders near the slipway. Members considered whether it might have formed part of a slipway or pier, potentially incorporating an older structure, but deferred conclusions and planned archaeological assessment and sampling. Researchers Corian Moll and Chris Morford presented a speculative theory linking geometry in Nicolas Poussin’s paintings and Nolan’s Cross to the “Eye of the Swamp”; the team agreed the area warranted investigation while emphasizing that physical evidence was needed. Geoscientist Ian Spooner subsequently reported that sediment cores from the eye showed disturbed, interlayered deposits consistent with possible excavation or other human activity, which he estimated occurred around the late seventeenth to eighteenth centuries. A separate sample suggested the swamp began forming around 1220 AD. Spooner said the findings raised the possibility of substantial human manipulation, while the team recognized that further data and intact archaeological evidence were needed; he also agreed to examine a historical map attributed by researcher Zena Halpern to a Templar voyage.
- Episode 10, Gary Strikes Again (January 21, 2020). At Smith’s Cove, the team exposed a large oak-log-and-clay structure near the slipway. Archaeologist Laird recommended careful hand excavation, and the team agreed that any dismantling would require his supervision. Gary Drayton recovered a metal object beside a log that he initially believed might be silver, but Dr. Christa Broussard’s analysis identified it as impure lead containing tin and antimony. Subsequent lead-isotope analysis by Dr. Chris MacFarlane suggested a possible western Mediterranean origin, including Italy, France, or Spain; the team planned further testing to better understand its composition and provenance. At the Money Pit, drilling near the historical Shaft 2 tunnel recovered hand-sawn lumber at approximately 108 feet and sand enclosed in clay. The team interpreted these findings as possible evidence of the tunnel and a water conduit, suggesting proximity to the original Money Pit, and considered additional drilling to confirm its location. In the swamp, the team obtained excavation permits, drained most of the area, and brought in a specialized tracked excavator after consulting contractor John Skirko. Work began near a previously identified stone walkway, with the aim of investigating that feature and other targets; earlier core analysis had suggested substantial seventeenth-century human activity and that the swamp might have been artificially created.
- Episode 11, The Eye of the Storm (January 28, 2020). The Oak Island team accelerated its investigations as Hurricane Dorian approached. In the swamp, excavators recovered wooden stakes resembling survey markers previously found by Fred Nolan and decided to preserve and test them. They also attempted to expose a submerged stone area, but persistent water and mud prevented them from determining whether it was a constructed surface; a drainage trench was dug, and further work remained necessary. At Smith’s Cove, Gary Drayton and Jack Begley recovered an iron cribbing spike near the slipway. Blacksmithing expert Carmen Legge assessed several similar spikes as likely predating 1820 and potentially dating to the seventeenth century, suggesting they may have reinforced a heavy wall or dry dock. The team also collected timber for tree-ring dating to compare its construction date with the known 1769 slipway. In the Money Pit area, drilling near the suspected end of the Shaft 2 tunnel recovered hand-cut wood at approximately 106 feet. The team considered it a possible indication of older workings, potentially including the original Money Pit, but planned scientific dating before drawing conclusions. Before Dorian’s arrival, the team secured equipment and materials; afterward, it found the swamp flooded and the causeway damaged and unsafe for heavy equipment, while Smith’s Cove had suffered no apparent damage. The team planned causeway repairs, road and tree cleanup, and at least a week of swamp drainage before access to the affected excavation areas could resume.
- Episode 12, Fortified (February 4, 2020). After a hurricane reflooded the swamp, the team resumed pumping and planned to expose a section of the stone feature to determine whether it was natural or artificial. Dendrochronology of a red spruce sample from a Smith’s Cove log structure returned a date of 1741, earlier than the previously dated 1769 slipway and the 1795 discovery of the Money Pit. The team regarded the result as evidence of substantial early activity and decided to investigate a possible connection to the French at Fortress Louisbourg. Rick Lagina and historian Doug Crowell visited the fortress with historian Sarah McGinnis, examining its original stone drains and plans and photographs of a countermine tunnel; they noted similarities to features investigated on Oak Island, though no direct connection was established. On Lot 27, Gary Drayton’s team found cut lead tentatively identified as musket-ball casting waste and an encrusted iron object thought to be an old axe, possibly a ship’s rigging axe; their dates and significance remained uncertain. Once the swamp was sufficiently drained, the team exposed part of the relatively flat, closely fitted stone surface. Geoscientist Ian Spooner concluded that the arrangement and sediment layers were unlikely to have formed naturally, while archaeologist Laird Niven also considered it man-made. Spooner proposed that it might have served as a work surface near a former inlet, but its purpose, date and builders remained unknown; the team planned further exposure and profiling.
- Episode 13, Bromancing the Stones (February 11, 2020). Rick and Marty Lagina’s team investigated a layered stone surface in the Oak Island swamp and considered its purpose and extent. Geoscientist Dr. Ian Spooner concluded that the stones had been deliberately placed, citing a stick compressed beneath a rock as evidence against a glacial origin; he proposed dating the wood to help establish when the structure was built. Further excavation exposed similar stacked stones that may have extended the paved area, and the team planned additional work to define its boundaries and look for artifacts. Rick and historian Doug Crowell also reported similarities between the swamp stones and eighteenth-century paving and drainage construction at the Fortress of Louisbourg, although a connection to French activity or treasure remained speculative. Near the swamp’s “eye,” Gary Drayton and Jack Begley recovered an old pickaxe and spade and proposed having them examined; their age and any connection to tunneling were not established. At the Money Pit, a new core encountered undisturbed but loose ground, leading the team to consider repositioning the drill. Separately, radiocarbon testing dated wood from a previous core to 1626–1680, a range the team noted overlapped with Spooner’s estimate of late-seventeenth-century disturbance in the swamp. Finally, a permitted excavation at the Dartmouth Heritage Museum followed a reported sighting of the missing ninety-foot stone, but the team concluded that it was not in the searched area and intended to continue pursuing other leads.
- Episode 14, Burnt Offering (February 25, 2020). The Oak Island team reviewed a wood sample recovered approximately 106 feet deep from borehole FG12 in the Money Pit area, which had been dated to as early as 1626. The result led the team to consider the location a promising candidate for the original Money Pit and to investigate the feasibility, timing, and equipment needed to install one or more large caissons. At Smith’s Cove, archaeologist Laird Niven advised a cautious excavation of a wooden box structure to determine its depth and purpose. Part of the structure collapsed during the work, prompting the team to stop digging and backfill to protect the remainder; the exposed structure did not appear to connect to the stone box drains being sought. In the nearby Uplands, excavation uncovered a substantial timber structure and an old nail that metal-detection expert Gary Drayton tentatively dated to the early nineteenth century. The team considered whether the structure had been built by earlier searchers and planned further excavation to explore a possible connection to a flood tunnel. In the swamp, the team recovered an iron strap near a stone-paved area and sought blacksmithing expert Carmen Legge’s assessment of it and other finds. Legge identified one object as a hand-forged pickaxe dating approximately to 1750–1790 and assessed the strap as a sailing-ship timber brace typical of 1710–1790, with signs of exposure to intense fire; he identified another suspected digging tool as a thin metal plate. The team discussed whether the findings and a previously detected anomaly might indicate a buried or burned ship, but recognized that further evidence was needed.
- Episode 15, Surely Templar (March 3, 2020). The Oak Island team investigated a ship-shaped seismic anomaly in the swamp, recovering a wooden stake and a metal object before dense clay forced them to pause trenching short of their target depth. Blacksmith Carmen Legge later identified the metal object as a possible sailing-ship pole point dating from approximately 1710 to 1790, although its connection to the anomaly remained unconfirmed. For the Money Pit investigation, Marty Lagina and Craig Tester agreed with ROC Equipment CEO Vanessa Lucido to deploy an eight-foot-diameter excavation casing and a larger hammer grab, offering substantially greater sampling capacity and a better chance of penetrating bedrock; the plan followed the identification of Shaft 2 near the reported original Money Pit location. Theorist James McQuiston presented a speculative account linking early Scottish settlers, Freemasonry, the Knights Templar and the Money Pit’s discoverers. Separately, archaeologist Laird Niven obtained a permit and began a systematic, near-surface excavation of Daniel McGinnis’s former property, including areas where ground-penetrating radar had identified anomalies. At Smith’s Cove, the team exposed a substantial timber structure, potentially a collapsed tunnel or the historical Shaft 5, and encountered a strong flow of water. Geoscientist Ian Spooner confirmed that fibrous material recovered there was coconut fiber, consistent with historical accounts of material used near the cove’s flood drains. The team planned to continue excavating to determine the structure’s depth and whether it connected to the suspected flood tunnel.
- Episode 16, Water Logged (March 10, 2020). The Oak Island team excavated an old timber-lined shaft in the uplands near Smith’s Cove, seeking a suspected flood tunnel connected to the Money Pit. Coconut fiber and two iron spikes found in the area prompted questions about whether the shaft predated known nineteenth-century search operations. An interim seismic survey identified a prominent linear anomaly approximately 60 feet deep between the Cave-in Pit area and the Money Pit; the team prioritized investigating it and deployed a long-reach excavator. At roughly 50 feet, they observed substantial water inflow, but unstable ground and a cave-in forced them to withdraw and backfill the excavation before confirming a tunnel. At Saint Mary’s University, Dr. Christa Brosseau and Dr. Sean Yang found phosphorus in both spikes, indicating they were likely manufactured before the 1840s and possibly from the same batch; the analysis did not establish that they predated the Money Pit’s 1795 discovery or determine their origin. The team also drained and excavated the Eye of the Swamp, where they examined a stone-and-metal formation, blue clay, tree stumps, iron associated with a stump, and a concentration of large boulders. The stumps suggested the area had once been dry, but the team had not determined whether the stones were deliberately placed; they decided to preserve the exposed formation and consult geoscientist Dr. Ian Spooner. Separately, Rick Lagina and Gary Drayton found a piece of lead on Lot 17 and discussed possible testing to compare it with other lead finds.
- Episode 17, To Boulderly Go (March 17, 2020). The Oak Island team investigated a boulder formation near the swamp’s stone-paved feature. Geoscientist Dr. Ian Spooner said the surrounding sediment appeared to have accumulated quickly and that he could not identify a natural process that explained the stratigraphy, suggesting the stones may have been placed deliberately. In the Smith’s Cove uplands, excavators exposed a substantial wooden shaft or possible tunnel near an earlier water-filled excavation. Hand-cut timbers resembled those from the previously dated 1769 U-shaped structure, and camera footage showed timber supports and an opening; however, the team could not establish whether the feature was a flood tunnel or an earlier searcher’s shaft. Members agreed that dendrochronology results would be important in deciding whether to return to the site. The investigation ended for the year because the cofferdam permit was expiring: Irving Equipment began the several-week removal, after which the area was to be backfilled and restored under environmental requirements. At Daniel McGinnis’s former property, archaeologist Laird Niven identified structural remains, a probable trapdoor entrance to a deep cellar, and a decorated bone-handled knife tentatively dated to the second half of the eighteenth century; further excavation would require an expanded heritage permit. Separately, geochemist Dr. Chris MacFarlane reported that a lead artifact contained unusually high mercury and tin and had an isotopic signature consistent with sources in Greece, Cyprus or Turkey. The team discussed possible links to document preservation and Templar-associated regions, but these remained speculative.
- Episode 18, The Turning Point (March 24, 2020). Rick and Marty Lagina’s team prepared a larger Money Pit excavation using eight-foot-wide steel caissons and a heavy oscillator, with a target depth of approximately 202 feet. The operation followed core drilling that uncovered ax-cut wood in borehole FG-12, reportedly dating to more than a century before the Money Pit’s discovery. In the swamp, geoscientist Ian Spooner and archaeologist Aaron Taylor assessed the stone-paved area and the nearby “eye.” Taylor considered the unusually level paving intentionally constructed, while Spooner proposed that the eye had been excavated to extract clay; Taylor suggested the paving might have supported carts transporting it. Both the purpose of the features and any connection to the Money Pit remained unconfirmed. Further excavation exposed a similar rock layer and substantial water flow, which Spooner considered likely connected to the paved area, although its function remained unclear. At Samuel Ball’s protected former property, a ground-penetrating radar survey identified anomalies that could indicate buried walls or another structure. Archaeologist Laird Niven said the preliminary findings could support an application for a permit to conduct test excavations. Finally, the team began the Money Pit drilling operation, inviting longtime island researchers David Blankenship and Dan Henskee to initiate the equipment.
- Episode 19, Lords of the Ring (March 31, 2020).
- Episode 20, Springing the Trap (April 7, 2020).
- Episode 21, A Leaf of Faith (April 14, 2020).
- Episode 22, Marks X the Spot (April 21, 2020).
- Episode 23, Timeline (April 28, 2020).